Hernando's Pizza Pub

Fun place with pizza that is hard to best this far west. Hand spun crust with honey, mmm. A must for Portlandia fanz.

Some of the best pizza I’ve had in Colorado. Been eating here for years, the quality has always been consistently excellent. My family’s go to pizzas are “Roma” style Sonoma, the Pesto pizza, and the Mediterranean pizza. Antipasta salad and clam linguine are also pretty good.

Amazing food, atmosphere, and service.The Garlic bread was excellent. We (my wife an I) couldn't figure out what was so special but in between this and the marinara, we were immediately amazed. The fettuccine alfredo sauce was amazing as well. Pizza was great, though we ordered thin and will definitely try the "rolled" Anext time. Service was great. The hostess, waitresses, and manager were all nice and attentive. Atmosphere was neat. Very unique and cozy. Will definitely be back next time we visit Winterpark!

This was our first restaurant stop in Colorado for our family vacation. The atmosphere was great. Loved the dollar walls. Kids thought it was great, they loved the decorations too.The food and drinks were another story. The only thing I really enjoyed was knowing it was cooked in a brick oven. It had that specific taste, but that was it. Pretty bland pizza. No other taste for the crust. The toppings were okay. The cheesy garlic bread and dip was bland. It left a lot to the imagination. $50 later; I wish we would have looked around a bit more.I dont want the 3 stars to reflect the workers or service there. Everyone was very kind and our waitress was very helpful. This may be a hometown favorite, like ours is to us.

As the #1 pizza aficionado in the world, I rate this place 5 stars. We have been coming here for 13 years and every trip is just as good as the first. Unique tradition of putting a dollar on the wall, makes for s great wallpaper. No need for dessert, putting honey on the crust makes for the sweetest touch.

I like it, that they have a whole wheat option for the crust. Only bad thing is, that they don't allow substitution. So if you are picky or allergic, you need to build your own pizza.

This place is awesome!!! Best pizza ever!!! Staff is great! Fast and friendly!

LOVED IT! very cool place. There are dollar bills everywhere. They are on the walls, ceilings, and at the bar. You just write whatever you want on a dollar, and you can staple it wherever you can find an empty spot. The pizza was excellent, and folks working there were very cool. They were social and helped us to have a good time. Lots of locals were here, and a guy that could perform magic showed our kids some magic tricks. Don't pass this spot up. Food is good, employees are friendly, and the atmosphere is fun.

Friendly staff and great food. Very vegetarian friendly. I had a hard time picking which item to get with so many good choices. Would recommend the vegetarian lasagna.

Ordered the “Roma” pizza. Super tasty. More on the doughy side but cooked to perfection.Great service and cool vibe in the restaurant. Pro tip... bring a dollar.

Best pizza ever. It's magical. Just try it. Should be on everyone's bucket list to go here!

Fast and attentive service. Pizza was fantastic and absolutely delicious. It was fun to color a dollar bill while we waited and then have it put on the wall.

This pizza is delicious and I'm from Chicago so I'm a pizza snob. Their cheese blend is the best part. The crust is light and flaky with just enough crunch just a hint of sauce inside giving it more flavor than many other crusts. I was told by locals they love it because it is very consistent and always good.

This place has been a family favorite since I was a kid. They have great pizza and wings but it gets real busy. It's a "mountain pizza" so expect a very thick crust to put honey on. They are pretty quick even when busy and their pesto pizza is to die for.

Rude, Rude, Rude! Hostess and our waiter were unpleasant to deal with and made it impossible to really enjoy the pizza experience. Not recommended! Find another place to spend your $$

Fantastic pizza, worth going for the food alone but the interior of the restaurant puts it over the top. I will be a repeat visitor.

I’ve been going to Winter Park for 20 years. If you don’t visit this place you are doing yourself a disservice. Excellent food. Love the cheesy garlic bread and the pizza.

Staff was friendly and attentive. Food was good. Parmesan cheese is served in a bowl with a spoon and there's honey in a squeeze container for the pizza crust. Our meal was a little over 50 bucks for 2 large pizzas and a 10 dollar dish of spaghetti with meat balls. Ambience is chill and the vibe is definitely a reflection of the town.

Pizza was ok. Not worth the 1.5 hrs wait for carry out.

Great pizza, whether you want a traditional pepperoni or less traditional BBQ chicken this place has it all in a variety of crusts. In addition to pizza they have excellent salads and hot wings. I was visiting from out of town and this place came highly recommended, I will definitely be back next time I am in town.

Overall, a good meal. I had Ravs and Rigs (cheese-filled ravioli and rigatoni noodles) with marinara sauce with spicy sausage. Was good, but didn't stand out from other pastas I have had. My dad ordered the lasagna and loved it! Friendly and helpful host and waitress. Nice environment for a family meal. Seating outside is available.

Awesome food and service!! A must stop and experience the local flavor and people!!

Spur of the moment in February, but smart enough to call ahead. Worth the wait. Wish we didn’t live 3 hours away.

Very good food, great atmosphere

The best. Great food. Great servers very friendly. Great atmosphere. Popular, very popular.

This is the spot on the mountain if you want 🍕... Very chill atmosphere and you'll most definitely make friends if you go... Oh yeah the pizza and drinks are dank too 😋

Great staff and ambiance. The pizza was good but I can't say it was great. It was a bit too sweet for me. 5 stars because taste is subjective. You may love it.

We ordered the Supreme Pizza with the garlic crust- Omg! It was so good! 14" was perfect for two people to eat & have leftovers back at the condo. Also ordered the clams & pasta, but wasn't too impressed- it was ok. Will be back for the pizza for sure!

The greatness of the food is proportional to the amount of dollars on the wall.

We liked everything about this place. Great ambiance, service, food. Beer selection is decent and the prices are great!! Pizza is definitely in the top 10% best I've had, which is saying something after living in NYC for 3 years. Crust is awesome! Wings are also really good too. Go on a Wednesday or Thursday and ask if Barryn is working. Expect crowds on the weekend.

Their pizza is delicious and the atmosphere is relaxed and casual. It's a great choice 😁

Fun and funky atmosphere with delicious pizza! What more could you ask for? The Mediterranean pizza was REALLY good.

This place has a very unique decor made up of 1$bills with individualistic art. We really liked the garlic bread, lemonade and the salad here. Pizza was really thick and lacked toppings. Also, they had really slow service when it came to pizza.

Another winter park classic. Definitely the place to go and sit down for pizza in WP. So many choices but we prefer to have the old school mason jars of coors light with one of their specialty pies like the Mediterrean, Column 1 or Supreme. We also usually get an order of wings. The old owners and the new owners are equally friendly and really support the local community (they donate to many, many causes). Highly recommended.

Hernandos.... I apologize for not being a regular sooner!!! We have been passing this place for 10 years on our way to our cabin. Why we haven’t stopped I have no idea. Pizza was amazing. Rivals possibly the best in Colorado. Tied for first day n my pizza book. We had the rolled crust Colorado style, but they also have a thin option. Had the 14 inch and had tons leftover. It was huge! Toppings are plentiful and loads of cheese. Red sauce was delicious. Pro tip: it’s happy hour at the bar all day every day. So if you are at a table and want to order shots, head to the bar and order them separate. Can’t wait to come

It's great pizza anyway but tastes especially good after skiing all day! It's a must whenever we are in Winter Park.

Really nice staff, and the food was tasty! Was great for after snowboarding^-^ we got a 10" pizza and it was about 3 slices for us both:)

Fantastic service, thick pizzas and great dollar bill atmosphere.

Interesting atmosphere(I'm not a fan of the tacky-looking dollar bills everywhere). The service was fantastic, the menu a little pricey, but it is a ski area. Pizza tasted good (didn't stand out), and very filling.

Old favorite. We recently moved back to CO and had a chance to ski WP a couple of weekends ago. Happy to see that Hernando's is still there and kickin' big time. Introduced my 9yr-old daughter to putting honey on the crust and now for the last 2 times we've had pizza, she'll ask for honey.

Amazing pizza, wonderful customer service. We called Hernando’s in the early stages of planning our wedding for a quote to host or cater our rehearsal dinner. I lost track of it and forgot to respond in all the craziness of wedding planning, and a few days beforehand Matt from Hernando’s called and texted me asking if we were still interested and he could get the order set up. We’d changed plans - but still needed lunch for our bridal party and family on the day of our Sunday wedding. The cooks came in early, before the restaurant opened, missing opening day of NFL games even, and made our special order for us to pick up. So incredibly service minded and kind of them. The pizza was delicious, of course, and none of us had to show up to the wedding hungry. It was amazing. Thank you guys!!!

Great pizza at this place! The ambience was cozy, and the walls were covered in dollars. Highly recommended. Great for groups. Long-standing local establishment.

The pizza was awesome. We got the Roma style, which I highly recommend. Service was great! My kids shared fettuccini with chicken and they loved it. Btw, there are over 35,000 dollar bills glued or taped to the walls, tables, ceiling, etc. It's pretty cool looking!

My husband and I have had almost everything on the menu and have always been very satisfied. The service is top notch (Dillon is our favorite server). Very unique atmosphere with a cozy fireplace setting and even a place to hang your coats! Wine and Beer menu is perfectly priced with selections that go wonderful with all of the food! Don’t forget to try some of the honey on your pizza crust it’s delicious! My favorite restaurant in Colorado!

Great place with an awesome atmosphere , great service and food!!! Happy hour drinks are always on and the food is great! First visit for me, but will return next time we ski WP! Get there early, the place gets very busy and even the to-go orders get pushed out! Wait the wait, it’s so worth it!!

My family has been coming here for 20 years. Best pizza in Colorado hands down.

Great prices and decent food. We only tried their pizza and wings and the pizza was better than average for sure and the wings were very meaty and had lots of flavor. The pizza was over cooked therefore the crust and toppings weren't as good as they can be. We can tell this place has great potential and we hope we just got a bad pizza.

Highly recommend! Delicious pizza! Have gluten free crust too!

The perfect pizza spot with a cool story to their iconic environment. Reminds me of SKOB in Siesta Key 👏 perfect za and great service, the right way to end a ski day. PS, keep an eye out for our dollars.

Awesome food, reletively quick take out. One star deducted because I had to go back in to get basic to go paper products.